Problem Solver Kimberly Vaughn Levels-Up the Claims Experience

March 13, 2023

Throughout Women’s History Month, we will feature female change-makers and leaders at Amerisure who are providing an industry-leading experience and making an impact within the insurance space.

Kimberly Vaughn has applied her expertise, passion for great outcomes, and emphasis on teamwork to deliver second-to-none service and grow in her career – and she’s not slowing down anytime soon.

Kimberly Vaughn, Stars of Claims
Kimberly Vaughn, Presenting on stage at Connected Claims 2022

In her role as vice president of claims experience & customer analytics at Amerisure, Kimberly is focused on providing an exceptional claims experience for agency customers and policyholders. She is responsible for developing and executing a roadmap for the claims customer experience and uncovering ways to leverage data and provide insights to policyholders that positively impact their loss experiences.

Claims Experience Organization – A Unique Service Approach

Kimberly’s passion for commercial insurance and a collaborative claims process is reflected in the strength of her team – the Claims Experience Organization (CXO). Officially launched in November 2021, the CXO serves a broad portfolio of customers and policyholders by facilitating connections, solving problems, providing critical data insight, and supporting the delivery of a consistent claims experience.

In its first full year and as part of the company’s One Amerisure service value proposition, Kimberly and the CXO team accomplished a number of feats, including instituting policyholder welcome kits to onboard new policyholders to Amerisure’s service offerings; rolling out account and agency-level dashboards for easy access to claims data; streamlining the claims review process by centralizing the scheduling, coordinating and creating action plan packets; supporting the company’s field marketing & underwriting teams to earn new business; and hosting policyholder presentations and training.

Building Up Those Around Her

Kimberly believes the most effective work environment is one in which a team can sort through many ideas by sharing them aloud, and building off one other’s ideas to ultimately create a better product. Her leadership style can be described as “clear and direct” – she believes everyone would rather be operating with the shared set of information and prefers to make transparent decisions.

Kimberly has a passion for teaching and inspiring other professionals within the industry. She also believes in recognizing opportunities for women and recommending talent within her professional orbit.
“I have personally been the beneficiary of those who have given me a chance to professionally develop,” said Vaughn. “I would not be where I am today if I hadn’t been given those chances.”

Kimberly has made significant contributions to the advancement of younger colleagues, especially in helping them build their confidence. When asked to offer her insight to young women thinking of joining the industry, she shares: “I love to tell young professionals, ‘Own your seat at the table, you’re there for a reason.’ I am passionate about encouraging women colleagues to plan their future and own their place in their professional universe. This helps to move them out of the common mind frame of ‘who am I to say?’”

Making Waves

Kimberly Vaughn triathlon
Kimberly at the starting area of a triathlon

Kimberly has experienced growth both personally and professionally and strives to try new things. She is a member of the Ann Arbor Triathlon Club, which has over 200 members. She has served on the board of the club, including as president, and as a member of the board helped cultivate a welcoming environment to all levels of athletes, whether elite or casual.

Kimberly’s favorite sport is swimming, and she is a certified lifeguard and a U.S. Masters Swimming Adult Learn-to-Swim certified instructor. She spends time serving as an instructor at the YMCA to coach water-shy adult swimmers. This activity allows Kimberly to positively influence the lives of other adults outside of her professional landscape.

“My area of specialty is working with adults who are scared of the water. Many of my students start too afraid to even put their faces in the water. The day my first-ever student treaded water in the deep end without my help, we both cried! It is really rewarding,” said Vaughn.

Looking ahead, Kimberly is excited about further developing claims team talent and coaching future leaders for Amerisure, as well as continuing to serve as a positive influence on the insurance industry.




About Kimberly Vaughn

Kimberly joined Amerisure in 2013 as a member of the technical claims team, focusing on high severity and high complexity Workers’ Compensation claims. In 2016, she was promoted to Assistant Vice President (AVP) of Workers’ Compensation Claims, before moving into the role of AVP of Claims for the North Region in 2018 and then launching the CXO in 2021. She began her career practicing law in Chicago, first as a member of the plaintiffs’ bar, then as a defense attorney, before returning to her home state of Michigan to join Amerisure. She earned her Bachelor of Arts and Juris Doctor degrees from Michigan State University and is licensed to practice law in Illinois and Michigan. She is admitted to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, the Northern District of Indiana, and the United State Supreme Court..

Kimberly earned the Certified Litigation Management Professional (CLMP) designation in 2015, the Advanced Claims Professional (ACP) designation in 2020, and the Construction Risk and Insurance Specialist (CRIS) designation in 2021. She is active with Chief, an organization connecting women executive leaders, the Claims and Litigation Management Alliance (CLM), previously serving as dean and faculty member for the CLM Claims College School of Workers’ Compensation, and with RISE Professionals, an organization supporting young professionals in the insurance industry.  She is a frequent speaker on industry topics, most recently with Reuters, ClaimsXchange, and the CLM’s Litigation Management Symposium.